A beautiful villain

I found one of the culprits that can cause cucumber wilt on some milkweed plants in a backyard nearby yesterday — the very attractive orange and black Squash vine borer moth (Melittia cucurbitae).  It’s too bad they are such damaging pests in the garden because they are quite photogenic.

squash vine borer moth sipping nectar from milkweed

It looks like a wasp from a distance with its striped body and long dangling legs, but is actually a member of the clearwing moth family (Sesiidae).

Long, highly “feathered” back legs drag behind the body as the moth flies, making it look like the wasp that it is trying to imitate.  But the clear, moth-shaped wings give it away, although these are not really visible to the human eye because they are moving so fast, they almost disappear.

squash vine borer moth on common milkweed flowers

The wings are just a gray blur in this photo, and you can clearly see the long proboscis inserted into the nectary of the milkweed flower — a very un-wasp like head. It looks like those hind legs also have some sharp spikes on them, as well as their feathery covering of scales.

Many of the species in the Sesiidae family are active in the daytime and are brightly colored, yellow and black or orange and black, mimicking bee or hornet coloration. This Batesian mimicry (in which a palatable species mimics an unpalatable or predatory one) presumably reduces their chances of being eaten by predators while foraging on flowers in the daylight.

squash-vine-borer on swamp milkweed

At rest, the mimicry is closer to the real model, since its folded wings do resemble the shape of a wasp’s.  (This is probably the culprit whose larvae wilted my cucumber vines last year — feeding on the swamp milkweed flowers in my backyard.  You can read more about that here.)

Other members of the Sesiidae family are also agricultural pests, infesting fruit tree, vegetable, and timber crops, as their larvae bore into the woody stems or trunk and decimate the interior vasculature system of the plant.

The Clearwing Hummingbird Moth (Hemaris thysbe) is no relation to the garden villain above.  It’s a member of the Sphingidae family of hawkmoths, and although the larvae do feed on honeysuckle vines and some fruit trees, they don’t do nearly the damage that the Sesiidae species do.

Clearwing Hummingbird Moth nectaring on flowers of an Apocynum species

This photo is from a recent post on critters of the northern bogs and forests, but the Clearwing Hummingbird Moth can be found almost everywhere in North America from Alaska to Florida.   Hawkmoths have a stouter, less slender body, shorter legs, and no scales on their legs, compared to the Squash vine borer moths. 

I’m not sure what the significance of clear wings is in these very different clearwing moth species.  Perhaps lack of scales on the wings means less air resistance during hovering flight, which both types of moths use for nectar foraging; or perhaps clear wings enhance their mimicry; or perhaps clear wings just present a smaller target to potential predators, since they appear almost transparent while the moth is flying.  Whatever the reason, the convergence of species from two different moth families is an interesting one.

15 thoughts on “A beautiful villain

    • I don’t use pesticides because that would kill the pollinators too. I pulled out the wilted plants and resolved to try a different method next time.

  1. Ugh. Can’t stand those pests. I haven’t seen any in my garden this year but that doesn’t mean they aren’t there. I get hit every year. I don’t use chemicals and find what works best for me is successive plantings. I have a ‘honeypot’ zucchini plant early in the season and then two more plantings so I can at least get some production. So far, the honeypot is healthy.

    • That sounds like a good plan. I would plant more cucumbers after the moths have gone, but it would be too late in the growing season to get any cukes.

    • Fortunately, this moth was not in my yard, but in a local garden. However, I’m sure they are around here too. Thanks for your comments about the gardening woes; I see that you have struggled with worse infestations than I have actually.

  2. The first shot is amazing. I had no idea that there was another moth with clear wings (I’ve seen the Hummingbird one before). Once again you educated me as I sought to discover what you had photographed me. Of course, you’ve complicated the identification process–I obviously will need to look beyond the clear wings.

    • I think the ID will be easier than you think. The hummingbird moth is much fatter bodied, and doesn’t have those long hairy legs. Apparently there are multiple species of the Sesseid moths everywhere, but this one is the first I’ve noticed.

  3. Beautiful! I was sure this was something you’d only find in the States but I’ve checked and there are 57 species in the family in France! Got to look closer! Then I thought it was related to the Hemaris that I see but you scotched that theory as I read on. Amelia

    • Yes, you undoubtedly have some of these unwanted pests in your garden. Fruits and vegetables crops in your garden are likely targets. Good luck with finding them.

Please Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s